Get your own personal stylist to help you find clothes you love. All online, completely free

Sign In

Style Advice

Our stylists discuss how to wear cardigans

Our stylists discuss how to wear cardigans

If you think cardigans only have a place in wood-clad studies, now's your chance to reconsider. Our stylists recently took to Slack to discuss their favourite ways to pull off the often midunderstood knitwear – as well as a few of the styles they think you should probably avoid. 

Toby: Howdy @luke @alexander

How're your lockdown fits looking these days?

Luke: Pretty good. Comfort has definitely become a focus, between the beard and the Birkenstocks, I’m basically becoming my dad.

Toby: A great look.

Alexander: Yeah, I'm working on the beard too, and I’ve been gravitating towards knitwear, as it’s not quite hot enough for me to be wearing shorts and t-shirts.

Toby: Brings us to today’s discussion: the humble cardigan. I'm a big fan of them in general, but especially as an at-home look.

Luke: Is it rad or grandad?

Toby: It's grandrad.

Alexander: Are you looking to channel a bit of Cobain @Toby?

Toby: Always! This Alpaca cardigan is on my wishlist right now. 

Alexander: That's nice.

Luke: Very Cobain.

Alexander: You can oversize on it and rock it with mid-blue jeans.

Toby: It's got an air of punk but without looking costumey, which I like.

Luke: Yeah, I think that’s key, right? My girlfriend had told me that I look way too old man with a cardi, but I was wearing one two sizes up recently, and she was like “that looks great” – it’s all about how you style it. 

Toby: I feel like I don't see you in one enough.

Luke: I really dig how classic this cardigan from M&S is. Just plain lambswool, oatmeal grey colour, and it’s styled really simply. Feels like for years cardigans were a bit too tight, thin, and in merinos, but chunky seems to be key.

Toby: Yeah I really like the simple ones. The OG right here.

It's been a proper cross-era garment hasn't it?

I always forget about the early 2000's technicolour cardigan fever dream.

Can imagine you in those days @alexander – rocking a yellow cardigan and graphic tee...

Alexander: lol

Not gonna lie, I did have a cardigan phase. Can't show you the images from back then though...  

Toby: This knitted cardigan is more your current vibe though I feel.

Photographed: MVP Full Zip Knitted Cardigan ($68)

Alexander: Yeah, that’s more my style now. I have to have something that feels modern. Contemporary vibes.

Luke: This knitted jacket from Oliver Spencer feels like that to me. The spready collar, the texture, and the snaps are just a bit more stylish. Especially if you’re not going oversized.

Alexander: I'm a sucker for a cardigan with a spread collar.

Toby: They've really nailed it.

Alexander: It's a good alternative to an overshirt. I'm feeling the tone of this cardigan right now. 

Photographed: AMI Patch Logo Cardigan ($399)

Toby: Such a great colour for this time of year. Great weight to it too.

That’s the problem with all my mohair stuff – you can only wear it for like three months out of the year. #gothproblems

Luke: I think another controversy that we have to cover: Shawl collars, love em or hate em?

Toby: I'm on the fence to be honest.

Luke: On the plus side is “The Big Lebowski” – Steve McQueen in the 60s. On the downside is kind of everyone else.

Toby: I think they can look great – if you're Kurt Russell with his hench winter beard.

Alexander: How big of a style icon is The Dude?

Luke: If you’re a beardy rugged David Beckham guy, it can work. Our head of business Development Terry pulls one off really well with workwear/military surplus type clothing, but it’s a really tough one.

Toby: I mean, this is the look for that style, right?

Luke: Basically you want to look like a handsome Jesus. 

Alexander: That's a vibe for sure

Toby: You're on the way with that beard, Lukey.

I feel like this cardigan is a good alternative for that shawl-collar look.

Alexander: Most guys just end up like this, but worse.

Toby: Yeah not a vibe. It would look so much better with a spread collar or v-neck style

Alexander: All joking aside though – I can imagine a shawl cardi looking alright in the right setting. If you are in isolation in a cabin somewhere. 

Toby: Yeah I think the right guy can look great.

Alexander: Next to the fireplace.

Toby: What an image.

Alexander: Comfortable in your armchair after a long day... chopping wood.

Luke: I think I can wrap this up with the most mental cardi on Thread from our former head of content Tom B’s favourite brand, “Wacko Maria”. 

Toby: That's a different fireplace mood.

Luke: If you are feeling flush with £459 and want to look great, look no further.

Alexander: I guess that’s for the afterparty.

Words: Allison Pavlick